Sales and Use Tax Compliance: Ruling in South Dakota vs Wayfair Case Concerns Small Sellers

Aaron Giles • Apr 20, 2018
south dakota v wayfair case

 

This past Tuesday April 17th the Supreme Court of the United States heard oral arguments in the case of South Dakota vs Wayfair, Inc. It’s not often that our country’s highest Court hears a case about state sales and use tax. In fact, the last significant sales and use tax case heard by the Supreme Court was Quill Corp. v. North Dakota in 1992 which set the precedent that out of state retailers are not required to register and collect sales and use tax unless they have a physical presence in a state. Obviously, much has changed in the online retail market since that landmark 1992 ruling.

 

 

In some ways it was a surprise that South Dakota vs Wayfair, Inc. was taken up by the Court because on its face the South Dakota law appears to clearly contradict Quill . In fact, the South Dakota Legislature acknowledged that the law may be unconstitutional at the time it was drafted. Regardless, the law was enacted, controversy arose and after a rather quick escalation through the state and U.S. Court Systems  South Dakota petitioned the Supreme Court with a writ of certiorari in October 2017 . The petition was granted in January 2018. Because the Supreme Court accepted a case that appears to relate to a matter previously decided, much speculation abounds that South Dakota has the advantage and that the Court would like to overturn Quill .

 

Further support for this line of reasoning can be inferred from Justice’s Gorsuch’s concurrence in a 2016 case regarding Colorado’s requirement for out of state sellers to bear some responsibility for sales and use tax compliance reporting. At the time, Justice Gorsuch was a Judge at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit in Denver, CO. Additionally, the position taken by Justice Kennedy in his 2015 concurring opinion in denying the writ of certiorari in Direct Marketing Association v. Brohl clearly demonstrates his support to reconsider Quill noting the “changes in technology and consumer sophistication” which have taken place since 1992.

This past Tuesday there was much concern expressed by the Supreme Court Justices about “small sellers” and the sales and use tax compliance burden that may be placed on them if Quill were to be overturned. Much of the concern relates to whether the Wayfair ruling would be prospective or retroactive. South Dakota ceded ten of its thirty allotted minutes before the Court to Malcolm L. Stewart, Deputy Solicitor General for the U.S. When asked by the Court, Mr. Stewart left no doubt that in his mind the ruling would have to be retroactive. All businesses that currently sell to out of state markets and are relying on Quill’s physical presence test shudder at what this could mean for them financially.

The Court seems to be aware of this potential financial pitfall for businesses that would all of a sudden find themselves out of compliance with sales and use tax reporting requirements. Some Justices appear to feel that the problems of sales and use tax registration and ongoing sales and use tax compliance reporting would be solved in the marketplace by entrepreneurs through software or additional service offerings. Other Justices appear concerned about the potential for states and other jurisdictions to go back and try and recoup as much money as possible from businesses that previously had no requirement to report sales and use tax.

While it appears that the final decision is too close to call at this time, the discussion from the Courtroom this past Tuesday was very interesting. A full transcript of the oral arguments can be found here. A ruling is expected near the end of June 2018.

a man with a prosthetic arm is using a laptop, he has received a sales tax exemption
26 Feb, 2024
Maximize your savings with Agile's insights on Alabama's sales tax exemption for prosthetic devices.
a man is driving a forklift in a warehouse, Arizona transaction privilege tax exemption for forklift
12 Feb, 2024
Explore Arizona's transaction privilege tax exemption for forklifts in our informative blog. Unlock potential savings and navigate the details efficiently.
two women walking down the street with shopping bags, economic nexus guided the amount of sales tax
06 Feb, 2024
Explore the economic nexus landscape across states, navigating tax obligations and thresholds. A comprehensive guide for businesses to stay compliant.
2024 Sales Tax Holidays
By Aaron Giles 29 Jan, 2024
Sales tax holidays give shoppers a break from paying tax on purchases. Many states offer sales tax holidays to boost consumerism and help their local economies. In some cases, sales tax holidays are held on multiple dates throughout the year. They may be inclusive, meaning all items are included in the tax-free shopping, or they may be selective, in which case only certain things are part of the sales tax holiday.
Michigan Sales Tax Exemption for Prosthetic Devices
By Mike Martin 03 Jan, 2024
The Michigan sales tax exemption for prosthetic devices has been expanded by the Michigan Department of Treasury’s response to Agile Consulting Group’s recent ruling request. The Tax Professionals at Agile Consulting Group, a proud member of the Michigan Ambulatory Surgery Association (MASA) , received updated written guidance from the Michigan Department of Treasury’s Tax Policy group regarding the Michigan sales tax exemption for prosthetic devices. From Agile’s recent experience at the MASA 2023 Education Day and subsequent interactions with its members, most Michigan Freestanding Surgical Outpatient Facilities, licensed under Part 208 of Michigan’s Public Health Code , and Hospitals, are aware of the law
Implants that Qualify for Michigan Sales Tax Exemption
By Aaron Giles 22 Sep, 2023
Explore Michigan's Sales Tax Exemption for Implants: Learn about the changes in the law, which prosthetic devices qualify for exemption, how to recover overpaid sales tax, and get expert insights from Agile Consulting Group.
Texas Sales Tax Medical Exemption for Hospitals Includes Many Categories of Purchases
By Matthew Soifer 25 Aug, 2023
In addition to the Texas sales tax medical exemption for orthopedic devices and appliances provided in the Zimmer ruling, there are several other categories of exemptions available to Texas hospitals and healthcare providers. Texas Tax Code Ann. § 151.313 provides a sales and use tax... The post Texas Sales Tax Medical Exemption for Hospitals Includes Many Categories of Purchases appeared first on Agile Consulting Group.
Arizona Transaction Privilege Tax (“Sales Tax”) Exemption for Manufacturing
By Aaron Giles 07 Aug, 2023
Arizona allows manufacturers in the state to purchase machinery and equipment directly used in the manufacturing process “transaction privilege tax” exempt. Arizona Sales Tax Exemption for Manufacturing While Arizona does not technically collect sales tax, they do collect transaction privilege tax which is treated in... The post Arizona Transaction Privilege Tax (“Sales Tax”) Exemption for Manufacturing appeared first on Agile Consulting Group.
missouri sales tax payment
07 Aug, 2023
In the state of Missouri, manufacturers qualify for a variety of Missouri sales tax payments related to their purchases of machinery and equipment used directly in production of tangible personal property sold at retail.
Show More
Share by: